Disclaimer: All analysis was taken from the TV coverage, so at times it may have been hard to identify players or what was happening, because I was limited by their footage. However, I have tried to be as accurate as possible and apologize for any inaccuracies or omissions (which I am happy to correct).
After the jump, I try and answer some of your earlier questions. If you have any more, please leave them in the comments and I’ll respond tonight.
Why did Pouha get pancaked on the TD run – poor technique or just overpowered?
I’ve watched it several times and can’t figure out how that happened. Levitre just tackled him to the floor and fell on top of him. It may even have been a hold.
What was the deal with Kerry Rhodes?
I rewatched the play where he seemed to back away from tackling the runner and later claimed to be “setting him up” for Revis to attempt a strip from behind and, as dubious as it sounds, I guess it’s possible that this was what he was doing. He took an extremely conservative angle to the ball and effectively shut off any danger of Lynch going all the way, but then compounded the issue with a weak shoulder bump, although he did spin off and get back into position to help finish off the tackle. The end result? Lynch got down to the 15, whereas Rhodes could have taken a shot at him on about the 28. Maybe that was what Rhodes was doing, but next time, just hit him, Kerry! Of course, we know he wouldn’t deliberately back out of a tackle, because “other teams are watching”.
As for the rest of his game, as noted by Bassett earlier in the week, he was back in his usual role by the second quarter, mostly in downfield coverage. Hardly any throws were made in his area, which is a positive thing because it shows he had his guy/area covered (unless the Bills were deliberately keeping him away from the ball in the hope that he might do something reckless in a desperate attempt to make a play that wasn’t there.) The two throws that were made in his general direction were a pass over the middle that Owens dropped, with Rhodes delivering a decent hit and a pass to the sideline, which Owens caught for a 15 yard gain as Revis passed him off to Rhodes in the zone, perhaps a little too early. Kerry had no chance of getting to the sideline from where he was at that point, but he did shove Owens out for his only tackle.
He was hardly ever in the box and when he was there weren’t many opportunities for any of the safeties to make tackles with the front seven playing so well. His highlight was a play where he came on a run blitz, which forced the runner back inside where Bart Scott stuffed him for a loss. The lowlight? Some people have suggested that he “quit” on Lynch’s TD run. It’s impossible to tell, but I didn’t see it that way. He blitzed off right tackle and Lynch started up the middle and bounced it left to the endzone. Rhodes’ path was blocked by an offensive lineman, so it looked like he tried to find a way to stop the run up the middle, only to find that path blocked too and by then Lynch had gone. He didn’t appear to quit on the play as much as he just tried to change direction and lost momentum, taking him out of it.
Overall, a quiet day for Rhodes, but other than the failed bait-and-strip, he didn’t do anything to hurt his team and they didn’t appear to be any “plays to be made” that he left on the field this time. Eric Smith had a quiet day too, but did have a good hit on the quarterback on a 4th quarter blitz.
What about the offensive gameplan?
Without going into detail, the gameplan in the first half was solid and the conservative gameplan with the lead in the second half was how this team was expected to try to win games all season, so I can’t have too many complaints, especially with the disruption caused by Sanchez’ injury and how well the defense was playing. Most of the “special” plays they tried (2 end arounds, 2 full back dives) had positive success, but they failed a couple of times when trying to get Woodhead involved (although Sanchez found other receivers for first downs a few times with Woodhead covered). Also, running a bootleg with Clemens on 3rd down was worth a try, and kept the clock moving, but had a low probability of success and the short screen to Cotchery would have had to be perfectly executed to have any chance of working. He’s called worse games though, certainly.
What about Lito?
Yes, Lito was great, a different player that we have seen since September. The most impressive thing is that they hardly threw over to his side, so he must have been covering well. He did get beaten early for a long catch by Lee Evans, but recovered really well to make the tackle immediately. From then on, he was extremely solid, making a good open field tackle after a short catch and twice breaking on the ball to break up passes, one to the outside that could have been a pick six and another over the middle which almost deflected to Revis. He looks healthy, which is good, but if he continues to play this much and the Jets are still in contention, he will probably exceed the 40% snaps threshold that could cost the Jets a pick (by my rough calculations, two more “full” games should do it). Still, if he plays this well, it might be worth it.
Did Gholston play on defense at all?
I’m pretty certain he did not. [Insert your own snarky comment about whether he has played at all this season here]. Interestingly, though, several other young guys that we hoped would get a chance to play down the stretch did see increased playing time, including Cole, Slauson, Woodhead and Westerman. It will be interesting to see if Gholston gets a shot once his injury is better. Right now, he is not a threat to make the 45% snap count that will earn him about $4m if he manages it in one of his first four seasons. (Note: this has been included in his “guaranteed money”, even though it is far from guaranteed).
How about the linebackers?
I didn’t analyze them in depth this week, but Scott and Harris combined for 18 tackles and were both excellent. Again, Scott was lined up on the weakside on running downs, but the strongside on passing downs. They and the outside backers all contributed to the pass rush, as analyzed yesterday.


Well done. People are being too hard on Rhodes. How is he supposed to make plays if he’s watching center field all the time?
There’s a report now that the Jets will let Lito leave in free agency, but I don’t understand why they would if he keeps having games like he did on Thurs.
MEL, I agree with you that Sheppard is good but only when he is healthy and obviously the Jets don’t want to risk having Lito injury himself again and again so they will go in another direction.
Bent, your evaluation of the offensive playcalling seems a bit tough. You seem to suggest Schott didn’t do a very good job (“he’s had worse games” and “not too many complaints” sure isn’t saying much), but neglect to include the several touchdowns the players left on the field.
I think a little more credit is due here- we know the criticism will be there when the playcalling is truly bad.
I haven’t generally been a critic of Schottenheimer and my analysis of the earlier Bills game suggested he got a raw deal.
I didn’t mean to come over as tough, I did think he called a good game. I guess I shied away from heaping effusive praise on him because of the anti-Schott crowd!
Rhodes is such a little girl, if that was troy p., or merriweather, or even Leonhard, they would have hit him at the 28 and tried to force the fumble themselves. Rhodes was waiting for revis to make the tackle for him because Lynch is too strong for him
Bent-
Haha fair enough. Didn’t mean to suggest that you had been the culprit for earlier Schott-bashing.
I go back and forth on him myself, but I do think people tend to only see the bad. Have you ever seen him get any credit, for example. for the success of the running game?
jon in bk,
The reason he doesn’t get credit for the running game is Bill Callahan is the Running Game Coordinator. He essentially is the offensive coordinator for the running game, but he doesn’t call the plays.
Brendan-
I knew people would bring out Calahan’s name on that one, but still- do you know that Schott had nothing to do with designing the running plays? That he has nothing to do w/ coaching the RBs (Callahan is the o-line coach, not the “running game coach,” at least in title)?
And are you suggesting that the play-calling has had nothing to do w/ the ground game’s success? Last I checked the Jets were by far the most run-happy team in the league, yet people crucify Schott for passing too much. Seems to me that he does a decent job mixing it up to keep pressure off the backs, and that on plenty of passing plays there are open receivers who just get missed.
Bottom line- the Jets this year are a slightly-below average O w/ bottom-3 production out of the QB. Obviously 18th in the league doesn’t cut it, but I could certainly see Sanche’z maturation taking them to the top 10 range, and w/ a great D that could be enough for a championship down the road.
jon bk
Im not trying to be a d*ck but honestly Callahan designs EVERY running play for the Jets. Its common knowledge. Mangini brought him in here last year to help Schotty do that. Which actually turned out to one of the Mangidiot’s better moves.
I here ya though that Schotty does call all the plays, so he should at least get credit for using the right ones to be one of the best statistical running attacks in the league
http://sports.espn.go.com/nfl/news/story?id=3203231
He is an assistant head coach, not just an offensive line coach. He is in charge of the running aspect of the offense. Although the Jets run the highest percentage in the league, they should have still been running more in certain situations. Sanchez shouldn’t have 30 (or within a few passes of 30) attempts in 6 games, but he does. That’s the issue. The past 2 weeks as Rex took a bigger role in the offensive gameplans Schotty has been more conservative and the offense has looked much crisper and efficient. I have been highly critical of Schotty this year, but his past 2 games have been good in my opinion.
Bent – These were great posts this week – thank you.
Jon – like Eddie says, Schottenheimer still gets credit for the play calling (and a raw deal from those who criticize him for not running more, because they are stuffed more often than not with a lot of people in the box, so forcing the run just creates a lot of 3rd down passing situations).
However, it is correct that Callahan was officially named the RGC. Look back at film from 2006 and 2007 when the Jets running game struggled. Although the personnel was somewhat to blame, as Brick and Mangold weren’t fully developed and Clement and Clarke struggled, the Jets only really had 4 running plays: a draw play up the middle, an end around to the WR, a quarterback sneak and a toss/pitch to the outside. Now they have a versatile running game with complex blocking schemes which can only have come from Callahan.
What is the compensation if Sheppard exceeds the 40% snaps threshold? A 4th rounder?
Of Note – another misc observation was Leonhard’s attempt at tacking Lynch on his TD run – I expected Leonhard to make a diving tackle/hit at the 10, but instead tried to tackle him high and was easily overmatched and dragged into the endzone.
Yes, a 4th (per Cimini).
Leonhard gets a pass because of his broken thumb.
You have one of the best run blocking fullbacks in the league in T Rich,(look at all the pro bowl rushers he has blocked for), you have the 2 top rusher in the league since 05, and you have 4 first round picks on the o-line. A monkey could coach the Jets running game successfully! Schotty is a very good coordinator, it is just as he makes the mistake a lot of young coaches who are touted as “brilliant” make, sometimes he out thinks himself. For instance his excuse for having pass happy game plans has been “they knew we were gonna run so I was trying to confuse them”, where a veteran coach would say “you now what we are gonna do stop it. I’m gonna go with my strength to win, not my weakness.” Sanchez gets the most criticism for all the picks, some should fall on Schotty. The game plan was supposed to be run, run some more, keep it simple and not let Sanchez do to much. When we stick to it we win. And that is keeping it simple.